Technology, Venture Capital, Private Equity

Perspectives from an Indian VC

  • Hi there!

    Welcome to my blog! I am currently working for a PE/VC firm in Mumbai, India. If you are a technology entrepreneur or company looking for funding, feel free to drop me a line on arunuday@headlandcp.com

    Disclaimer: Opinions expressed herein are my own and are in no way connected to those of my employer.

  • a

  • Recent Posts

  • Blogs that link here

  • Page Views

Short equities, long commodities

Posted by Arun Uday on September 22, 2008

Like everyone else in the finance world (and actually elsewhere as well), I have been watching with obvious interest, the unfolding of events in the past few weeks. And needless to say, they have been quite discomforting. While I don’t have anything particularly positive or negative to say about the actions that the US Fed or other central bankers have been undertaking to mitigate the crisis (most of them were actually Hobson’s choices), I do however feel that this may be a case of postponing rather than solving the issues unless we are favored with some generous doses of luck.
Ever since the financial crisis began to unfurl, a few things have been happening. To begin with, there has been a flight of capital to safe assets, which has squeezed out all liquidity and credit in the system. This has led to a bizzare situation where from the threat of inflation a few weeks ago, the US is now staring at a sudden deflation in the economy. So, what has the fed done? – it has started pumping up money supply and inflating the economy to maintain the liquidity and keep the economic wheels turning. But there are a few things which will really work against this strategy in the long run.
First is the overhang of credit that the US carries from the past. The credit expansion in the recent past has been unprecedented and the total estimated debt in the US, which includes national and private debt is $53 trillion (thats nearly four times its GDP). With all the bad debts that the financial institutions are burdened with and with economic prospects looking dimmer and not brighter (which in turn will affect the repayment capacity of borrowers), banks and financial institutions are not going to start lending in a hurry. So, the credit unwinding process would be a long and gradual one and its not clear how the central banks can continue to shore up liquidity till then.
Second, the record capital account deficits that the US has been running already put the greenback on a weak turf and unleashing ever increasing amounts of dollars will most likely cause a precipitous drop in value of the dollar (both against other currencies and/or intrinsically) sooner or later. So, it is possible that we could see a sudden and steep rise in inflation at some point in time.
And finally, we have the worldwide commodity crunch and the ever increasing demand for resources that we are witnessing, which puts immense pressure on its prices. I realize that there have been various analyses floated on this topic, and I don’t claim to have researched this topic to any degree of rigour, but from all the reading I have done so far, its clear that the absolute demand for resources is growing at a far greater pace than the matching supply. This to me is really what could be the steepest hurdle in any path to recovery. If this were not the case the monetary measures that the central banks have been undertaking could have aided the healing process in which with increased liquidity and falling prices, demand would shore up and economy brought back on track. However, with the large nations/populations in the developing world (China, India, Middle East) consuming ever increasing amounts of resources, this process may not follow the same pattern that it has in the past, when the predominant consumers were only to be found in the developed world.
Therefore, I am not so convinced that the long term equities story still remains in tact (be it in India or elsewhere) and that, with every dip we should be buying equities. In fact, I’ll say that in the medium term, on account of the above mentioned factors, the underlying story for commodities is what looks extremely strong and if I were a hedge fund manager today, thats where I’d be putting my money especially in case there are dips in their prices. The only things that could impact that reasoning would be – technological advances like clean energy etc, which would ease the demand for resources or, massive discoveries of new sources of resources. Else, in the medium term (i.e. 5 year horizon) my recommendation would be – short equities & long commodities.

Advertisement

2 Responses to “Short equities, long commodities”

  1. Shankar said

    Until recently, the US-dollar has been safe. However, since 1990 Western Europe has been busy growing, swallowing up central and Eastern Europe .

    Very few aware that the US was engaging the first oil currency, or petro-dollar war. After the invasion of Iraq in March 2003, remember, the US secured oil areas first. Their first sales in August were, of course, in dollars, again. The only government building in Baghdad not bombed was the Oil Ministry!

    For the US , the petro-dollar must be saved as the only way to buy and sell oil – otherwise the US economy will crash, and much more besides.

    In line with what you had stated (USA’s debts of $53 trillion), staying away from a debt-ridden dollar makes economic sense.

    That will bring us to the problem for so many countries now is, how to get rid of their vaults full of dollars, before it crashes? And the US has bullied so many countries to hoard the greenback for so many decades around the world, that many will see a chance to kick the bully back.

    The US cannot accept even 5% of the world’s dollars — it would crash the US economy dragging much of the world with it.

  2. tjo2151 said

    I couldn’t agree more that the solutions being considered currently are more focused on postponing the entire damages rather than actually facing the problem. It seems most proposals are aimed at finessing the crisis when we could be working on solutions. I suppose a lot of this precaution is due to the market’s tendency to collapse at the slightest hint of instability, but this balancing act the Fed/Paulson is trying seems to be having the opposite effect of settling fears, especially when the bailout didn’t even pass the House today. Very disconcerting.

    I think outside of a miracle this is going to be a lengthy economic stall that will bring harsh realities and the sooner Americans face that the better. I take a little comfort in the technological changes you mentioned, especially clean energy tech as a new source of business/investing but it’s just one happy side note.

    Quality post though.

    Theo O’Brien

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.